Hearts are broken when the boys return from Casa Amor on 'Love Island'
Thank goodness the Villa Therapists, Justine and Caleb, are in.
September 14, 2020 10:00 a.m.
Latest Update September 14, 2020 4:09 p.m.

CALEB AND JUSTINE
These two tall drinks of water reunited to become the new power couple in the villa and we’re happier than an Islander who just got a text. They give the best advice, they stayed loyal to each other, and Caleb can pull off borderline cheesy lines like, “At the end of multiple days it was still you.” The king and queen of the castle are back.Reunited. ? #LoveIslandUSA pic.twitter.com/19F52BQ0M2
— Love Island USA (@loveislandusa) September 14, 2020
JOHNNY AND CELY
Surprising no one but Johnny, Cely was upset that the guy who said he was 100 percent all in with her had to 100 percent make out multiple times with Mercades to be 110 percent sure he liked Cely. Carrington’s aggressive neck rubbing during Johnny’s lengthy recoupling speech was a clear indicator that he knew the storm that was coming after having a front row seat at Casa Amor.Johnny did his best to put the blame on Mercades before "putting the ball in Cely’s court," aka: apologizing once and then forcing Cely to convince herself that he wasn’t a waste of her time. Caleb told Johnny to stop justifying his actions, take a step back and nurture their relationship. Justine told Cely that Johnny, not Cely, looked dumb (well actually, "dumb as hell" were her exact words). See? Best advice!Cely let Johnny sweat even more than he typically does for an entire day before agreeing to move forward with their relationship. Be the man Cely deserves, Johnny.The Amor aftermath. ? #LoveIslandUSA pic.twitter.com/JRSHw9FV9r
— Love Island USA (@loveislandusa) September 14, 2020
MACKENZIE AND CONNOR
The biggest shocker of the night went to Mackenzie, who picked Jalen, leaving Connor alone with Gus the teddy bear. Earning his title as "Nicest Guy In the Villa/World," Connor delivered a beautiful speech about how much he cared for Mackenzie without appearing to be a doormat. It’s a balance. “I do feel hurt right now. I do feel like I was a little taken advantage of, a little slighted,” said Connor. “I chose to be loyal, committed and keep my trust there for you. I have nothing but amazing things to say about you and I hope that the person that you chose can see that in you as well and help you grow to be the person you’re meant to be.” Dayum, that is a nice dude.Not everyone had kind words for Mackenzie, including the OG guys, who all wanted the couple to break up before now. Shouldn’t they be celebrating Mackenzie for finally making that happen? “I’m glad you’re not with her,” said Johnny. “I think she’s a manipulative liar and I have little to no respect for her. You owe her nothing,” said Caleb. Harsh, said us.Mackenzie was happy with her decision to recouple with Jalen, but the honeymoon phase ended fast and Mackenzie quickly found that her love tank was not being filled. Jalen spent most of their first day as a couple trying to take Caleb and Justine’s jobs as the Villa Therapist (bro, do you even have a PhD from Love Island Medical School?). More specifically, he wanted to make sure that Kierstan knew she was beautiful. So beautiful. The most beautiful woman he’s ever seen. Roh row.The bros are NOT holding back. #LoveIslandUSA pic.twitter.com/3855jaktCy
— Love Island USA (@loveislandusa) September 14, 2020
KIERSTAN AND CARRINGTON
Kierstan stayed true to herself and decided to stick with Carrington even though they ended things before he left the Villa. Carrington picked slow-walking Laurel and gave a speech during the recoupling ceremony that Kierstan called "condescending" and Calvin called "savage." We called it "the most we’ve ever heard Carrington speak at once." Even after his speech, Kierstan was still interested in Carrington. Love yourself, Kierstan.Some occasions are too serious for an arm chug. #LoveIslandUSA pic.twitter.com/Tw1OAlPSlg
— Love Island USA (@loveislandusa) September 14, 2020